Wow, it's like the OP was reading my mind when starting this thread.
I'm in the planning stages of the next amp project and for various reasons I've been looking into Tweed. I have various flavors and variations of Blackface already: Fender Super Champ, Allen Old Flame (BFSR flavor), Allen Chihuahua (BF Champ with extras). I also have the non Master Volume Marshall thing down in the 18 watt format of my Trinity sIII V6. Although the itch for a Hiwatt (Triwatt) and Vox/Matchless/Trace Elliot (TC15) won't go away, the Tweed itch is stronger.
In the post above mine and in my other thread (
http://www.trinityamps.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?f=16&t=3243 ) Coco has laid out the recipe for dialing the Tramp for 5F1 Champ tones. Oddly enough, my initial round of questions on the Tramp were along the lines of how well it could do the bigger Tweed stuff (i.e. Deluxe and Bassman), since I've been pleasantly surprised by how much I like Reissue Bassmans and even the CVR as an alternative to the standby BF cleans. I was "concerned" that the little old Tramp may not do that. Basically, how far could the Tramp stretch in the bigger direction.
It never dawned on my to wonder about the Tramp stretching in the smaller direction, probably becasue it never dawned on my to care about tiny old Champs. I've owned some horrible sounding little tiny amps (basically toys) that were somewhat in the old Tweed Champ vein (e.g. Champion 600) and wasn't thrilled. But that was before yesterday when I strolled into a guitar shop to kill time at lunch (sort of like what I'm doing now during lunch in my office!) and tried out the Fender EC Vibro-Champ. Holy Fajitas, Batman! It was actually a fun little amp that really and truly did get that Layla album (think "Have You Ever Loved a Woman") tone with a Strat. [See the tail end of that linked thread for discussion on this very topic - especially about the attenuation] Champs all of a sudden became interesting.
Now, I actually wondered if the Trinity Champ could stretch into the
small direction and nail that Champ tone (albeit with a bigger speaker and a handful more watts). I started wondering if I should abandon the idea of a Tramp and look into a simple Champ clone with a simple L-Pad on the speaker output. I was basically asking myself the very question the OP used as the premise for this thread!
But Coco's recipe makes me think that a Champ may be a waste of time. If the Tramp can cover that ground (and offers two forms of attenuation to boot!) while still offering Princeton--->Deluxe--->Bassman-ish tones too, then a Champ becomes less appealing.
What's the "recipe" for bigger Tweed amp tones? Princeton setup? Deluxe setup?
And I suppose behind it all, there's those little push-pull pots and baby Marshall flavors there for the taking too, huh?