Revv23 wrote:
Does the room make a big difference when you are close micing? My instincts would say not much, but this audio engineering is indeed pretty new to me.
The room you are working in will effect EVERYTHING you do. Your recordings will sound better if you have a great room. Period. Close micing or not, the sound of the room will find it's way into everything you record... but perhaps even more importantly (and what is alluded to above) is how the sound of the room, the reflections, and the inevitable "nodes" or cancellations will effect how you hear what's coming out the speakers and the decisions you make...
HAVING SAID THAT...
I've been making records in untreated rooms for 22 years with great success. I'm not convinced that the work I've done in these environments sounds any different/worse at all to the work I've done in "proper" studios, perhaps even better in certain cases because of the "character". It's not that I necessarily "prefer" to work in an untreated room, it's just that with ANY room, including treated ones, you have to "learn" the sound of the room in order to do your best work. EVERY room has quirks, untreated ones just have more than treated ones usually, but that doesn't mean you can't make good music in them... there are a number of things you can do to minimize the sound of a bad room, but by far the biggest thing you can do to help with what you're hearing from your monitors is GET THEM AWAY FROM THE WALL AND OUT OF THE CORNERS!!!!! I see home rigs all the time where people complain they can't get the bass right and then see their speakers up against the wall or in the corners. It obviously means you need a bigger space, but if you can set up your monitors a good 2-3 feet away from any walls, you'll hear things A LOT better...
Some rooms are naturally better than others though, and some rooms are just plain awful. If you've got one of the awful ones, you'll probably have to treat it somehow because there will be things that you just simply can't hear coming out of the speakers... or find another room...
Bottom line, I'm not saying don't treat your room. What I'm saying is, figure out what's wrong with it through working in it, and experimenting, and hearing deficiencies in your work, and then attack those areas... Don't just start slapping up expensive foam because you think it's the right thing to do! If you're like me, you might just find ways to work around/with the quirks in your room (or even use them to your advantage when recording) rendering treatment a choice rather than a necessity...
And IMO what makes a room great is it's inherent qualities, not the treatment you put in it... my untreated chapel is without a doubt the best sounding acoustic space I've ever recorded in... to be honest, I'm almost afraid to do anything to it in case I change it!!!
Hope this helps.
_________________
Brent Bodrug
Producer-Engineer/Songwriter
www.slyfichapel.com