Both the Marshall 20W and 18W amps are cathode biased. So that's not something which differentiates them. The 20W is SS rectified and runs higher voltages, which gives the couple of extra watts of power. However, EL84s sound more sterile at 400V. It's not only about the warmth, but the rich complex harmonics you get from the 18W. If you want to tighten up the feel of an 18W you can use a huge cathode cap on the EL84s, in the 1000uF to 2200uF range to make the bias voltage stiffer. You can also use SS rectification, provided you keep the B+ voltage to around 330V.
Now there's no need for a rectifier switch, if you use SS rectifiers (preferably UF4007s) and a sag resistor. A value of around 100 to 120 ohms 7W will perfectly emulate the sag of an EZ81 tube. So you only need to switch the resistor in or out of circuit for when you want or don't want sag. The problem is with the rise in B+ voltage when you short out the sag resistor. The way to get around that problem is to use some zeners to reduce the B+ when in non-sag mode. It's all pretty simple to do.
And here are some previous comments from people who have played both the 2061 and the 18W.
nuttmeg1 wrote:
I've had a change of heart. Yesterday I had the rare opprotunity to sit down with Mike Doyle and play the 18w RI and 20w RI. We ran them into several cabs and we both agreed that the 18w was THE way to go. As he said yesterday,"This thing sounds great, (pointing to the 20w RI) if you've never heard that. (pointing to the 18w RI)
Brian
rjgtr wrote:
After reading the Guitar Player review I thought the 20 would smoke the 18. When I played both RI's the 18 just had a lot more magic than the 20.... I thought it was funny that Guitar Player seemed to favor the 20.... I think the low end growl of the 18 gives a much more full sound. Plus the trem is a lot of fun!
markd wrote:
I don't want to discourage anyone from building an amp, but the 20watt wouldn't do it for me without some changes. And then it would be an 18watt. ha! I have an original 20watt that I got to inspect the circuit, trannies, etc. I agree with everything that has been said. It sounds like a mid 70's Marshall(not that that is a bad thing). But I very much prefer the 18watt.
HTH